Hello to everyone involved. It looks like some interesting events have transpired within the last few hours. First of all, I want to thank you for bringing all of your comments and information to the forum and using our format as provided. It has been a very big help to me as I have spent the last 30 minutes or so pouring over all of the pictures and details.
I specifically would like to commend Temujin Khan's information, as the detail he provided via documented screenshots was a big help in determining my decision. I would also like to point out for the record that the screenshots that were provided by Jezzail, though helpful, included one error. The time discrepancy that was highlighted was no time discrepancy. That is a countdown timer on the tombstone that you see, not a time of death.
I find that, though the punishment may be severe, there was enough RP leading up to the event documented by multiple parties. The three 'deaths' are now considered confirmed. If any one of these three individuals are killed again within the stipulated 5 days cool down period (starting from 6/26/16 at 11:23am), their characters will be permanently killed (wiped from the server).
A note to those who rendered their fate. Your justice has been enacted for their stated crimes. To hunt them down to solely CK their character will be frowned upon. If, however, within those 5 days, these 3 continue to harass or go after you. Then by all means, they have no protection. This 5 day cool down period is also an attempt for players to cool down in real life too. It is a 'second chance' if it were if you understand my meaning.
On another note - Snow has turned himself into the authorities. He is being held by representatives of the Legion of Albion to stand trial. This has been sanctioned by representatives of Stirling and upon review with Lancaster, the interested parties will be able to attend and bare witness to a trial. No vigilantism while this matter is unconcluded.